Westerly Drops Vandalism Case Against Beachfront Property Owner

Charges against David M. Roth dismissed after he admitted to spray-painting over a shore access sign

A newly elevated right-of-way sign protected with plastic glass is shown at Everett Avenue in Westerly.
A newly elevated right-of-way sign protected with plastic glass is shown at Everett Avenue in Westerly.
Alex Nunes/The Public’s Radio
1 min read
Share
A newly elevated right-of-way sign protected with plastic glass is shown at Everett Avenue in Westerly.
A newly elevated right-of-way sign protected with plastic glass is shown at Everett Avenue in Westerly.
Alex Nunes/The Public’s Radio
Westerly Drops Vandalism Case Against Beachfront Property Owner
Copy

The town of Westerly dismissed a criminal case against a beachfront property owner police said repeatedly spray-painted a shoreline right-of-way sign in Watch Hill.

On Aug. 29, police charged David M. Roth, 76, with four counts of vandalism. Police believe Roth was responsible for vandalizing a sign that needed to be replaced multiple times over the summer because of the damage to it.

The sign is at the town-designated Everett Avenue public right-of-way next to Roth’s $10.8 million property. According to a police report, Roth told police he was upset about the sign’s placement at the access path, which he does not believe is a legitimate public right-of-way to the beach. Roth is not a newcomer to beach access disputes and is currently challenging Rhode Island’s new shoreline access law in court.

Despite the evidence police say they gathered, Westerly’s prosecutor, Robert Craven, said he decided to dismiss the case after Roth agreed to pay the town $1,010.90 in restitution. Craven made the decision under a rule that gives prosecutors discretion to dismiss cases, called Rule 48(a). Craven said he has dismissed other vandalism cases since being hired as Westerly’s part-time prosecutor in 2022.

This story was reported by The Public’s Radio. You can read the entire story here.

David M. Roth spoke with a Westerly police officer after his arrest on Aug. 29.
David M. Roth spoke with a Westerly police officer after his arrest on Aug. 29.
Westerly Police Department

The Department of Education announced that its office of Federal Student Aid will resume collections May 5
Unsustainable fishing, not climate change, has been the biggest threat to ocean biodiversity for decades. Scientists warn that dismantling marine protected areas could accelerate the crisis for species, ecosystems, and coastal economies alike
Union says incidents of violence against staff have risen 41% between 2022 and 2024
The measure, introduced by Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse and Rep. Seth Magaziner, is unlikely to succeed in the Republican-controlled Congress
Barrier was built without permission along less sensitive water around same time as Quidnessett Country Club’s controversial wall
Local Catholics reflect on the death of Pope Francis and the legacy he leaves behind here in Rhode Island
Invasive sea squirts are crowding out native species and clogging fishing gear, leaving scientists scrambling to track their spread
Brown and the Library’s mission is to ‘serve the community, the nation and the world by discovering, communicating and preserving knowledge and understanding in a spirit of free inquiry’