Can Animals Make Art?

Some philosophers believe that creating art requires intention and nonhuman animals, they’ll argue, simply don’t have the right kind of intentions for art-making

A male satin bowerbird stands before his creation.
A male satin bowerbird stands before his creation.
JJ Harrison, CC BY-SA 4.0 , via Wikimedia Commons
Share
A male satin bowerbird stands before his creation.
A male satin bowerbird stands before his creation.
JJ Harrison, CC BY-SA 4.0 , via Wikimedia Commons
Can Animals Make Art?
Copy

In the forests of eastern Australia, satin bowerbirds create structures known as “bowers.”

The males gather twigs and place them upright, in two bundles, with a gap in the middle, resulting in what looks like a miniature archway. All around the bower the bird scatters small objects – shells, pieces of plastic, flower petals – which all possess the same property: the color blue.

Studies suggest that the purpose of the bowers is to impress and attract females. But their beauty and intricacy has left some researchers wondering whether they shouldn’t be considered art.

Off the coasts of Japan, male white-spotted puffer fish create impressive nests to attract females. The male pufferfish uses his mouth to remove rocks from the sand and his body to wiggle out long, strategically placed grooves. The finished product is a multi-ringed sand mandala about 6 feet in diameter.

Like the bowers, the nests of the pufferfish are beautiful and involve mate attraction. Yet some researchers argue that since these sorts of works all look roughly the same – have the same shape, use the same materials and so on – they’re more likely the result of evolved, inflexible dispositions than more creative processes.

Of course, figuring out whether something is a work of art requires answering some tricky philosophical questions. Are animals even capable of creating art? And how can we tell whether something is a work of art rather than just a coincidentally beautiful object? As a philosopher and artist who’s interested in aesthetics and biology, I recently wrote about the evolution of behaviors in animals that could be seen as art.

Read more on The Conversation.

DiPrete led Rhode Island through a period of economic growth in the 1980s, but his legacy was marred by a bribery and extortion scandal that made him the only governor in state history to serve time in prison
From cancer labs to coastal climate tools, Rhode Island researchers join scientists nationwide in warning that federal funding cuts could stall lifesaving work
T.F. Green received a score of 84.9 in the annual Travel + Leisure magazine competition based on reader surveys evaluating airport amenities
The hospital allowed an unlicensed medical assistant to do a procedure prohibited under state regulations
Famiglietti, a personal injury lawyer who serves on North Providence’s town council, won more than 70% of the district’s votes in a four-way race